From read only, to read/write, to write only, to … ?
Posted: November 15, 2026 Filed under: Education, Opinion | Tags: AI, artificial intelligence, chatgpt, education, educational problem, reflection, technology, thinking, writing Leave a comment
Now this is long, if you want the 5c version, software developers using Generative AI are starting to generate large amounts of automated text that takes a long time to read, which means that the people checking their software are using GenAI to summarise it and accept the changes. This means that the human role in software oversight is potentially reducing, and quickly. Now to the long version.
The long-winded intro
The interactivity of networked communication has been an amazing development in human information transfer. Books, which are great, are large, physical objects, where you can read what I wrote but you can’t (easily) respond to me in a way that other people can see your thoughts on my writing. It was slow to write books with ink and pen and even the advent of the typewriter and word processor has only sped up the creative act of producing the text of a book by around a factor of five. Printing a book has got much faster, certainly, and electronic distribution of the written word has made it almost instantaneous from decision to print to “here is the book”, but it still takes time to write a book. If you assume a book length of 80,000 words, it’s about 133 hours of handwriting to to produce those words, or about 27 hours if you’re not a bad typist and don’t stop to eat, sleep, or breathe. This doesn’t allow any time for thinking, plotting, drawing complex diagrams, or edits, but it’s a way to think about how much human time and effort is required to write a book. I once wrote 50,000 words in just over 20 hours for a charity writeathon and I can tell you now that I could barely talk when it was done. Many authors write somewhere around 1,000 words a day, which would mean you’re waiting close to three months for a book. Actual writing, with content and thinking, takes time.
On the receiving end, humans read around 260 words per minute, far faster than people type and anyone handwrites, with that 80,000 word book taking a little over 5 hours to read (you have a comfortable chair). You don’t have to write a response to the book, you just read it, think about it, and you’re done. Of course, we’ve been sending each other much shorter messages than books for ages – messages sent by messenger, courier, or postal service to exchange business information and personal thoughts, have been around for thousands of years. But both of these have one thing in common in that the written entity is given to us and we never really modify it. A letter exchange has input from both sides but through the exchange of individual read only elements, with the time between letters determined by how long the first took to write, that one took to send, the time for the receiver to read and craft a response, and then choose to send it again. Individual letters could be collected, physically, or by being printed into a volume, but they remained a set of independent read-only messages.
One of the first new communication models to emerge after we started connecting computers together was simple messaging, then e-mail and discussion boards, and it’s in discussion boards that we started to see a read/write aspect to a conversation really emerge. Discussion boards provided persistent containers for the organisation of messages and responses to those messages (and responses to responses…), suddenly changing an information exchange between multiple people into something that could be changed by both parties. The ability to edit and change shared pages took this even further – Wikipedia, for example, is something many people read, but what you read is the product of hundreds or thousands of people in an ongoing conversation as they change any or all parts of the information on the page. LiveJournal, a long form social media site from the past, was often joked about as being “write only”, because users would produce long articles about things that mattered to them, shared onto a feed where others could read (and comment), but they ignored any comments that came their way as they weren’t interested in dialogue but broadcast. Books are broadcast. A set of letters can be a conversation, if stored correctly. A discussion board or social media site provides mechanisms to support a useful dialogue, with varying levels of editing older information, although sometimes it’s just people shouting at clouds.
Oh, Bruv New World
Under all of this is a simple assumption, that all the words were created by someone, with an intention of being read by someone else. This assumption broke a few years ago and this breakage is having some serious ramifications across a range of spheres.
The advent of generative AI means that novel length words can be generated in the blink of an eye by a short prompt, channeling the stolen work of millions of people to pump out a notional novel in seconds. It no longer takes 27 hours of typing, and goodness knows how many days of thinking, to produce a novel. Of course, another aspect of generative AI is using it to summarise works or reports for you, which means that it no longer requires 5 hours to read a novel – you can get a summary in seconds. This, of course, would have an immediate effect on fiction publishing, especially if people are happy to read AI generated work. If someone is still reading manually, there are only so many books that they can read in a year – which means the more AI generated ones they read, the fewer human ones they can read.
I don’t know quite what to call a model where an AI writes the book, and a human claims authorship, and then another person uses AI to summarise the book, and says that they’ve read it. It reminds me of the human/robot discussions of the late science fiction writer Philip K. Dick, who wrote about the blurred lines between creatures that say that they’re one thing but may be another. For me, and no doubt many will disagree, authorship requires both the creative intent and the work to bring it to fruition – ideas are cheap, effort is what brings them to the world. Someone writing large books using a small AI prompt is not, in my mind, an author. But I don’t have another word for it quite yet. I do feel that someone who is only reading short summaries of books has not actually read the book – they may have the gist, or even a good idea of the ending, but they do not have the knowledge of the way that the book was written or any idea of the many themes and nuances that were used in the book. Sure, they’re still reading but have they read this book? Sorry, I don’t think so.
Is this really new?
The generative contribution to verbosity is new. From the moment we made it easier for people to add volume to their text through cut and paste, whether physical or electronic, texts have been getting bigger. When legal judgments went from hand written to computerised, pages and pages of former cases could be added at no effort to the crafting judge. While this notionally added important information, this low effort inclusion of additional information put a greater burden on anyone seeking to read the judgment later. Before generative AI, this burden was shouldered by junior lawyers and clerks, as summarising the case required someone human to do the work. After generative AI… it has become far easier to generate a large volume at the start and then summarise it to (notionally) salient points without all the human labour. I say notionally as, of course, LLMs are prone to error and hallucination, and any generation or summary could be wrong. If a human is doing the summary, then they may spot a generative error – may.
At its core, we have to look at the role of the human in here. There is a finite limit to the speed with which humans can read and write, which limits the speed of producing and analysing written texts. No argument. But speeding this up, using non-human means, should probably not be at the loss of accuracy, quality, and usefulness of the information in question. The slowness of humans is a limit, not a benefit, but the price of using human intellect, training, and expertise is that they have a speed limit. We probably don’t want our legal judgments to devolve to “hey, Siri, give me 10 pages of why he’s guilty”, and “yo, read these 10 pages, summarise to one sentence and three bullet points for case for appeal.” The “didn’t bother to write it”/”not going to bother to read it” model has got some pretty obvious pitfalls in it, even in the simplest of cases.
Real World Impact
The didn’t write/didn’t read model is one we can look at in fiction as a curiosity, and get a slightly worrying feeling about it’s use in law, but there’s another place where DW/DR can actually cause trouble and that’s in the area of software development. For those who don’t know about large scale software engineering, it’s often built on a repository model, where the pieces of code are stored in a central repository that tracks versions, allows integrated testing, developers to exchange comments and raise issues, and, ultimately, makes large and intricate code bases easier to look after. A number of these are built on software called git, which is a distributed version control system, and developers can take a piece of code, change it, test it, and then, when it’s accepted, merge it back into the main software so that their changes are used in the current production version.
The online platform GitHub uses Git with a large amount of project management wrapping to let people from all over the world work on code in a controlled and systematic way. Ideally, for a given section of code, any changes are only being made by one person, all changes are properly tested, and then these changes are presented back to a moderator of some sort to check so that one person changes and one other person checks. The developer works on a branch pf the main software, makes changes, is happy that it works, then uploads it back to the server. Then they issue a pull request, where they compare what they’ve done to the main branch, add a description of what they’ve done, tag any issues they believed they’ve fixed, and ask someone (or nominate) someone to review their new code. This code is then run through automated tests and continuous integration systems to make sure it doesn’t break immediately, then what should happen is that a human reads through the PR, checks the code, writes any comments, and, once approved, the code is then merged to the main branch. This code is now part of the main build.
But what has started happening with the use of Generative AI is that the effort required to write long and copious notes on software changes is diminishing. If GenAI is generating your PR, it can lead to longer descriptions and longer issue statements. Now this wouldn’t be a problem by itself, except that the frequency of PRs are increasing as people use GenAI to write code to solve issues. Now the humans doing the review have got both more text to read in an individual PR AND more PRs. So what are they doing? There’s clear evidence that more people are using GenAI to analyse the code in the PRs and get a tick of approval. In some cases, the GenAI is authorised to do the merge if the PR passes muster.
What this means is that what should have been a benefit, increased code output and increased description, has now started to push people out of the checking loop. Code is being generated so fast, much faster than humans could, that it’s exceeding what the reviewers can handle, which means that they’re having to use Generative AI to keep up. And that means that true human oversight of code changes is reducing. And, remember, LLMs sometimes make things up, sometimes are wrong, and are often random in unpredictable ways – all code generated by them needs oversight, just as human written code does.
We’ve already seen an unpleasant dehumanising of lower quality educational systems where overworked teachers use GenAI to generate worksheets that performance-driven students use GenAI to complete and which are then marked by GenAI because the teachers don’t have time. A scenario where not only do we not have confidence that anyone is learning anything, but we literally have no way of knowing because all of it is being done by AI. This is potentially damaging and dangerous to students if left unchecked.
Now imagine a software future where Claude writes the code, ChatGPT writes the PR, Copilot does the checks, ChatGPT writes some comments, Claude notionally responds and then merges this to the main branch. Let’s assume that each of these is 95% accurate, the chances of this code and all of its documentation being correct is around 77%. Now humans are certainly not perfect but they are, in this setting at least, also not random in their solution seeking. Programmers work on a design, where a lot of the work in the software is done before any code gets written, often using tools such as very specific types of diagram, relational modelling, and markup languages, to ensure that the code, when written, is more likely to be accurate. Also, skilled software developers can be very good at spotting bugs in code and there is an intentional mental discipline and a set of semantics that underpin the writing of code – humans do not write code randomly and we know that they can have a far more detailed mental model of a system than any current LLM can manage.
After having six Severity 1 incidents in a week, Amazon backpedalled rapidly on their unsupervised deployment of GenAI-assisted code and now senior engineers have to sign off on everything. Suddenly, the Sev 1 rate dropped. Hmm.
Every time that I read about how much faster we can write code with GenAI, I am reminded of the Simpsons episode where Bart is trying to demonstrate his intelligence by playing chess against three people simultaneously (“The PTA Disbands!”, Season 6, Episode 21). Immediately after someone saying “Hey, that boy is playing three games at once!” he is checkmated on all boards, as he may be playing three people but he’s not playing well. GitHub has fallen over many times for capacity in the last two years as the change rate has exploded with GenAI code changes being pushed, but we’ve also seen a sharp spike in code revisions, where merged changes have had to be removed because they didn’t work and none of the tools used picked that up.
There are ways of using these tools to reduce some grindlike aspects of programming but they are nowhere near accurate enough to operate without some form of human oversight, and this means that humans have to be able to read and digest all of the associated documentation and code changes. The “Didn’t write/didn’t read” model is hard to justify in any setting but it’s extremely dangerous in the area of programming, as it is not mature enough to produce working systems at the same level of reliability as before, and it robs everyone involved of the opportunity to develop and maintain their skills.
I fear that we are just playing bad chess on millions of boards and that there is a looming wall of checkmates.
The Simplest Test of LLMs for Research
Posted: August 9, 2026 Filed under: Education, Opinion | Tags: advocacy, AI, artificial intelligence, chatgpt, education, higher education, reflection, teaching approaches, technology, thinking, writing 1 CommentI am teaching a general research preparation course for Masters students across my (shiny new) University called RESE 5000 Foundations of Research. It’s a four week course as part of a much larger sequence and covers research design, alternatives in research design, paradigms, quant/qual, and a lot of hands on work to develop a small but focussed research design glossary for these students. The useful part of this is that they have got more vocabulary and more knowledge with which to discuss things, especially with their supervisors. It’s all colleges and disciplines so it’s a pretty broad course in coverage.
The Activity
Because they have to go and find appropriate references for methods and approaches in their own discipline, we bootstrap with literature reviews: how do you find the papers and published works that support your research? I conduct a very simple exercise in the first workshop:
- Open up a Google Scholar page and search for a term I give them. (It’s often mastery learning.)
- Then we discuss as a class what we found as the top 10. It’s almost always exactly the same and, because inside the Uni we’re subscribed to all of the various pub venues, you can click on all of them and open them up.
- Then I ask them to open up ChatGPT (or “LLM of choice” if they have a strong preference) and ask it for top ten references for the same search term.
- And then we compare.
- And then we check to see how many are duplicates.
- And then we check to see how many don’t actually exist.
I did this on Thursday last week for the subject of mastery learning (told you), and of the ten references I got back, 2 and 3 were effectively the same, 10 didn’t exist, and two others kind of matched. But, more importantly, everyone got something different. We had gone from “this is what you get when you search” to “here’s something that might be right and it will change every time”. By my estimate, students who start with the LLM based approach need to spend up to twice as much time checking to make sure it’s not wrong. I think that’s inefficient.
The Rationale
I don’t use generative AI at all in my work, unless for specific research or illustrative purposes, although I am starting to work with Apertus, the Swiss-based model that meets EU training standards, is offset for power, and cooled by the waters of Lake Lugano. As a journal associate editor and regular reviewer, however, I am being driven to distraction by the sheer number of fabricated references I’m encountering. I have a very simple rule on this – you cannot build good research on bad research and evidence of reference fabrication is evidence of a flawed process.
I tell the students that how they use Generative AI is up to them, their supervisors, and whoever employs them, but I also tell them that good research is supported by solid citations. If I can’t run a simple demo in class and get right answers more than 90% of the time, this tool is not fit for purpose.
Oh, but you could craft the prompt/use agents
Yeah, I could. I’ve had students do that, where they change the prompt to only provide actual works that can be looked up. The first problem is that you still sometimes get dud references, the second is that this is most likely using some form of agentic checking layer over the top of the stochastic generation. Now, I am not a young CS person, and I cut my teeth coding for 16K, 32K, 640K memory spaces, which means that the aesthetics I value in code include efficiency and minimalism. With much of CS being searching and sorting, I find it more than vaguely irritating that the solution to “the machine is making things up” is not “stop using the machine” but “check what it made up to see if it worked and then throw the dice again until you get it right.”
Searching is not just about finding what is there, it is also about knowing what is not there and clearly indicating that. We used to value precision and recall, and I am seeing far too many false positives to make me confident that this is still being taken seriously. The speed with which a synthetic answer is generated when no answer truly exists worries me, because most people don’t check as much as I do.
The dull conclusion
There are things that AI is good at. There are things that Generative AI is good at. But given how easy it is for me to show students what it’s not good at, I’m going to keep recommending that they avoid it for reference generation for the foreseeable future.
First day at the new (old) job
Posted: January 5, 2026 Filed under: Education | Tags: AI, education, higher education, learning, reflection, teaching, writing Leave a commentI sit at the desk in my new office on Level 5 of the building I’ve been working in for over 10 years, as part of a different university and with a new job title. The foundation universities of the University of Adelaide and the University of South Australia are now officially merged as Adelaide University, which is now roughly the 5th largest University in Australia. I am no longer the Deputy Head of the School of Computer and Mathematical Sciences, as neither the position nor that school still exist! I am an Academic Lead in the School of Computer Science and Information Technology, with responsibilities around educational research and our education specialist staff, and now have roughly 15 staff to manage as part of our new model.
Last year was pretty successful in many ways, the ITiCSE WG delivered an amazing report with some fantastic resources, I was part of a successful grant, the CompEd WG made fantastic progress (still going into the new year as we tidy that up), and I felt like, for the first time in ages, I really had the opportunity to look into research into detail. But it was very tiring, being the last year of a long push that started during the pandemic and finishing in a year where I got so sick that my hair started falling out and my overall physical health took a 10% hit. Much better now, although my hair is still my hair! And now the universities are merged and I’m part of the brand new Adelaide University. It’s a great time to look forward and set some themes for this year. But let’s do a 50,000 foot flyover of my job.
Research: From a research perspective, the CARD WG outcome has reinforced how important it is to have learning resources and tools that lead to the outcomes that you want – this is especially true in the face of the rise of Generative AI, where it is terrifyingly easy to sidestep any cognitive or memory work totally in the production of artefacts. For years, we got away with requiring student to produce something as evidence of a process of production, which entailed cognition, learning, and application of effort over time. Artefacts like the CARD Research Cards can’t be completed with generative AI, people have to interact with them. There are opportunities to engage with something, consider it, respond to it, and develop your skills accordingly. I sketched out some ideas last year about a working group based on tools and approaches for learning that specifically could not be carried out with Generative AI, but haven’t done anything with them. I most likely can’t do any WGs this year for timing and commitment reasons but I might pitch something next year about all the ways that game-based approaches to learning and non-AI-based scalable aspects of personalised learning can be useful in the era of Generative AI. The random and reflexive aspects of the cards make the process inherently focused on the individual – but I’ll return to this thought later. More stuff needs to happen with CARD but that’s a next week thought.
Teaching: I’m teaching a couple of courses this year, mostly around the postgraduate level, working on research skill development and computational research methods. This will be the first curricular application of the CARD system, realised as both physical cards and an online version developed by our fantastic media team in the learning design space. It will be great to be back in the classroom more!
Leadership and Service: I have 15 direct reports and will be getting to know them over the next few weeks. I suspect I’ll be in three places in a given week, my old stomping ground next to the Art Gallery on North Terrace, City West campus, and Mawson Lakes Campus. Learning what they need, and how I can use my experience and knowledge to help them, is one of my highest priorities prior to the start of Semester 1. I have had an unconventional pathway to academia but I still have many lenses of privilege to acknowledge and work through when I work with anybody else. There will be a lot of listening and thinking on my part. I have a number of duties for various SIGCSE roles that I’m looking forward to getting back into now that I’m finally healthy again.
Travel: I’ve been travelling a lot and the plane trips have been frequent, long, and not the best thing for me in any sense. I’m planning to spend about three months in Finland this year as part of a visiting fellowship at University of Jyväskylä but this will involve less flying and more time concentrated in one place. I hope that this will allow me to do better work and be more present…
Speaking of presence, I think that’s my most important theme for this year: present in my personal life, present for my students, present for my research collaborators, and definitely present for my colleagues, especially those who I’m managing. Something has been showing up in my shape at various points of the year but I’m not sure how much of it has been me. Let’s see what I can do this year.
Happy new year, everyone!
Books about Play
Posted: January 27, 2025 Filed under: Education, Opinion | Tags: books, education, games, gaming, play, reading, reflection, teaching, teaching approaches, thinking Leave a commentBeing a subset of interesting books from my collection, accompanied with explanatory texts of varying utility, as well as references to this blog.
A very rapid summary in far too much detail.
I recently had reason to distill my thoughts on why games, play, and the playing of games were a valid and even necessary area of discussion when talking about education. Some collaborators and I have been working on a new way to assist in research skills development that uses play mechanisms. I have had a lot of opportunity to read and think about this but I wanted to get it out of my head so other people could also understand why I thought the way that I did.
However, I realised when I was trying to write up my books about games and play, that I had quite a large amount of philosophy and theory behind it, as well as some motivating examples from other educators. I can direct people to the books but unless I really explain at least some of the journey, the books are just islands of fact in a desert, when really most of what I have here are stations on a longer and much more detailed journey. As with everything, it is not the fact, it is the context in which you encounter it and your mood and willingness to engage when that fact and context are coincident.
I also realise that there is a chance that anyone reading this may need to skim this. You will still have the books by name, which achieves the initial goal, and it is quite useful for me to write all of this up so that I have a record of it, should anyone else ask. The excuse to do this has allowed me to invest the effort, doubly so now that I have modified the original version of the text for publication on my (long dormant) education blog.
The layout of the following sections will be a collection of books and then some discussion as to why they’re here. Some are just good examples, some are more illustrative, some are essential. I shall attempt to make the difference clear.
Robert A. Sage
Myth

Theodor W. Adorno
Aesthetics

Genis Carreras
Philographics

Don Norman
The Design of Everyday Things

Myth: Robert A. Segal
Play is a fundamental part of being alive, for many creatures, not just us. Because we can’t communicate well with other species, it can be very hard to understand what is a habit or somehow driven by the surroundings, what is a (conscious?) choice for a creature to under a serious action, and what is play: to engage in activity for recreational purposes or enjoyment.
Obviously, many activities have both serious and play applications, so understanding whether an activity is play or serious cannot be determined simply by observing. For me, my pathway to understanding play began by seeking to understand how we, the human we, work with information, how we process what has gone before, how we understand it, label it, categorise it, express it, communicate it, and interact with it.
Thus I started with trying to understand how we formed the understanding of our early selves. I have had a number of books on the formation of human myth, how we talk about our pre-history and pre-written selves. There are many books of myth but I like this (tiny) Oxford University Press book from Segal about contemporary theories of myth, which contains the great truth that theories of myth are often subsets of some larger theory from a given discipline restricted to the area of myth.
Myths are not just stories in word or voice, but there is often a tie to ritual, physical activities that are associated with a long held traditional story or belief. This book covers many angles of the theory of myth, discussing in brief many approaches, and it was a (much larger but) similar text that led me to understand the importance of the physical in story-telling and communication.
A good story has many elements to it, in the use of voice and physical theatre, in the choice of location, even down to the timing of the tale and its cadence. But we only have to look to puppetry, an ancient art, or how children react to the use of small wooden animals, to see how quickly our minds can wrap narrative and assistive explanatory tool together. The idea that this could reinforce a ritual, reinforce a memory, and hence give us a mythic form that might carry information forward comes from books like this.
To restrict the domain of play to either the physical or the non-physical is to ignore the reality that we engage in physical and intellectual pursuits for our own amusement. From a personal angle, I am a somewhat infamous juggler of words, which is more intellectual, but I was for many years a keen underwater swimmer, as my terrible swimming style is no disadvantage when submerged. Water was my medium of play for many long Australian summers, as long as I could stay underneath it competing with my friends, diving for thrown objects, or diving to the bottom of the deepest pools I could find. It was a break from reality, a different space altogether: concepts I shall return to later on. Play has turned out to a very natural thing for me, but it took a lot of reading to understand how essential it was to my humanity and my serious work as well.
Theodor W. Adorno – Aesthetics
The next book is a rather odd choice as this is a set of lectures delivered by Adorno in 1958-59, which he used to base a book on … that he never finished. Theodor W. Adorno was a German philosopher, musicologist, and social theorist. He was a leading member of the Frankfurt School of critical theory and wrote many fascinating works including the amazing “Minima Moralia“, which is worth looking at in its own right as it is a collection of short themed observations, many of which are profound in their expression and content. However, this book is here for two reasons:
- His definitions of aesthetics from Kant and Hegel and the ongoing discussion throughout the book are some of the clearest I’ve seen and show very clearly the difference between “aesthetic as decoration” and “aesthetic as fitness for.. everything”.
- His deep commitment to interactive work with his students, where his own intellectual understanding of the work and his desire to present it in an engaging manner resulted in his own students not quite following. Rather than not following, he corrected himself and reset his context. Reading this book shows you a masterful thinker and philosopher being relatively really rather humble and I love it for that alone.
Returning briefly to point 1, I shall recall that aesthetics can be briefly described as the philosophy of the principles of beauty (among other things). Well, what then is beauty? I’m glad you asked. Kant basically defined beauty as everything attractive that was not useful – a ‘disinterested pleasure’. For example, an apple could be beautiful and hence aesthetically pleasing until you ate it, at which point your interaction was animal and essentialist – having found function/value, your interaction was no longer aesthetic. Hegel disagreed, quelle surprise, with Kant and redefined beauty as “the sensual appearance of an idea”. Now we could still interact with something in meaningful ways and indeed incorporate function into our definition of beauty.
This immediately admits the aesthetic of form in function, where aesthetically pleasing objects are also excellent examples of form, as is seen in a great deal of Japanese and Scandinavian artisanal handicraft, where function without good form is anathema.
You have to read the book to find out how much Hegel then went on to get wrong, according to Adorno, but one more thing to remember is that Adorno rejected aesthetic sensibilities as somehow objective or rigid, they were strongly associated with whatever matter you were regarding and that was where you derived their sense. This notion of relativism is quite liberating, as it allows for a multiplicity of aesthetic interpretations.
Genis Carreras – Philographics
This is a recent addition to my collection and I bought because it was a reminder of the complex pathway people have taken in their attempts to render complex concepts as simply symbols. One of my many interests is in wayfinding, in the physical and intellectual sense; this being the work of communicating pathways and directions to other people. This leans heavily on semiotics, the study of signs and symbols and their interpretation, as no map for wayfinding would work without a very clear sign vocabulary.
There are so many books I could put here but this is already long enough. This book is here as a simple symbolic placeholder to the importance of agreed contexts for shared understanding of symbolic representations, a vital part of the language of play. The range of human interpretation of words, actions, and symbols is vast and understanding if someone is playful or serious often hinges on this understanding. (Consider the Australian slang ‘sport’, which can be one of the most serious and threatening words anyone hears. It is not clear at all that this is the verbal equivalent of three giant flashing red lights and a tornado siren.)
Contrast this with the two images from this book, which seek to explain different concepts with simple symbols. Do they work? Perhaps. Are they interesting to consider, to view as guides to our own symbolic representation, and thus the way that we could consider play? Definitely.


Don Norman – The Design of Everyday Things
And here we are with the classic. How does the great naked ape, Homo Sapiens Sapiens, interact with the elements of its world? Norman’s book explains mugs, handles, defining the requirements of the things that a human is going to try to use in their pursuit of love, life, and work. In design, affordances, what the environment offers the individual, are reduced to what actions you can perceive are valid with an object. I have often extended this into the ethical sphere, as I believe that well-defined ethics provide the affordances for living with other people: what are the valid “handles” that one can “grab” and still be considered part of the in-group?
From a play perspective, we are back in the realm of semiotics: what do I need to show you so that you understand that the available affordances are playful rather than serious? What does that even mean?
I also find Norman invaluable for thinking about requirements analysis, as a simple affordance test on a prototype is a great way to show you all the things that actual people will do. Of course, in HCI and UI-design, the fact that you cannot predict everything a human will do is often a core concern, but reading Norman can help you to think about finding a coherent interaction model despite that.
Summary
So we’ve looked at the way we talk about ourselves, to understand how we might communicate play and serious, started a definition of aesthetics, wandered into wayfinding, and appreciated affordances. Let’s walk a little further into design before we finally start talking about texts that describe play.
Helen Cann
Hand Drawn Maps

Tomitsch et al
Design. Think. Make. Break. Repeat.

Bleecker et al
The Manual of Design Fiction

Roger Caillois
Man, Play, and Games

Helen Cann – Hand Drawn Maps
Again, there could be many books here. There is always Korzybski’s “The Map is not the Territory”, which is a very solemn version of “All models are incomplete but some are useful.” Maps are representations of something in the/a world, most often visual and two-dimensional, showing the things that are of interest to the map maker and also hopefully the map user. (Korzybski’s statement may be read as that if something was exactly the same as what it was mapping, it would be the thing – therefore, all maps are not exactly the same so what do you choose to change.)
I like public transit maps, because they so clearly show how you can get around cities, are almost always well-designed, and have to be useful to a large number of busy people. They are some of the most effective maps you’ll ever see because they have to be.
Amusingly, the London Underground Map is only useful underground. There had to be an active “London aboveground” program to show Londoners how to navigate the world above, because some things shown on the Underground map gave a totally false impression of what sensible aboveground navigation would look like. Why? Because the underground map prioritises connections, a breakthrough design by Harry Beck in the 1930s because he represented everything as a schematic diagram, rather than a mapping of the geographical reality. People on trains don’t need to know if the track is straight or curved, they need to know how many stations until they connect to go three more stations to Tooting Bec. I wrote a lot more about this about ten years ago.
Helen Cann’s book takes a playful perspective on maps and is aimed solidly at people who are building maps for fun, which is why it’s here instead of some other very serious books. It contains many creative prompts for building visual 2D imagery that conveys spatial and other relationships in a way that helps you navigate them. Maps, boards, cards, and games are all linked in my head and her book helps to understand why this is and why they are all subtly different.
This also admits the kind of graph/connection thinking that we see in the works of Franco Moretti – the Distant Reading Guy – where he carries out corpus analysis and NLP to derive relationships, determine changes, and explore hypotheses, without necessarily every personally reading the text. I like his stuff as a tool but I’m not sure I buy it as a solid methodology. Again, there’s a couple of blog posts on this here. Maps are fun!
Tomitsch et al – Design. Think. Make. Break. Repeat.
This is a book of design methods, roughly 60 different ways to engage in design with many perspectives and disciplines. It’s basically a short reference to scaffold the development of knowledge in the area of design: from product design to user experience and much in-between. I like this book for several reasons:
- Each section has a clear description, a reference list, step-by-step exercises, and a number of handy templates you can just start using.
- It’s very focused on getting you started trying something, to build knowledge through hands-on attempts.
- It has some really interesting case studies at the back.
I haven’t just learned about design from this book, I’ve learned about how to learn about design, and how I could construct other materials to make learning easier. This book has helped me to communicate ideas about play.
Bleecker et al – The Manual of Design Fiction
The last of the design books! Design fiction is probably one of my favourite things (I have many and don’t usually rank them so this is less exclusive than it may seem). At its heart, design fiction is the deliberate construction of narrative prototypes to suspend disbelief about the possibility and benefit of change. It is, like all fiction, inherently playful. We are building castles in the air and then sending in virtual construction inspectors to find our faults! How much more fantastically playful can we get?
This work is part of the core thinking about play and the research skills development tool that colleagues and I are working on. How can I get someone to understand that there might be another way to undertake their research? Let me rewrite that: how can I reduce the barriers to explore change? How do I encourage people to consider that there may be techniques and thinking that are not nonsense from other disciplines but valid contributors to academia? Again, let me rewrite that: how can I change your mind about which paradigms and methodologies are valid?
This book is a touch focused in the physical/reification space when, to me, design fiction has as much, if not more validity, in the area of ideation and knowledge development – this may all be nuance and I may just need to think more. It’s still a really interesting read and will add enormous amounts of interesting food for thought around group work, collaboration, and skill development.
Roger Caillois – Man, Play, and Games
I am deliberately presenting this book first, although it is very much a reaction to the next book, Homo Ludens. Caillois’ book is about the definition of what play is, with a wide range of culturally located definitions of the key games of given peoples, linking games even to moral aspects of culture, defining customs and institutions.
He accepts the essential need of humans to play and defines it (partially) as a voluntary sidestep from the realities of life, wherein rules constrain action and we all move to some outcome that has at least some randomness in its achievement. Children tend to improvise more, adults tend to strategise more, an increase of discipline with age and knowledge, perhaps or just another custom? He links some games back to mythic connection, where the games played by children mimic the actions of gods long ago, sometime deliberately as part of religious practice.
There are any number of important terms introduced here, including alea, which is best understood as chance but has many other meanings. When Julius Caesar took his armies across the Rubicon and into Rome, to take it as Emperor, he is supposed to have said “Alea iacta est.” which means “The die has been cast/I have taken my chance.” This statement is significant in its appeal to the fates, but also a recognition of uncertainty and a clear statement of bravado! (Recall that the study of probability is terrifyingly recent and many earlier cultures regarded what we would think of as random outcomes as clear indicators of favours granted by supernatural powers.)
Caillois took issue with Huizinga’s work, as he felt it lacked recognition of the variations of play and the needs served by play in a cultural context. While Caillois is, to me, the better text in terms of its utility because of its cultural inclusion, it’s still important to read Huizinga.
Summary
All of this is designed to provide tools, vocabulary, and background to really start to understand that games are important, culturally and personally, which provides us with a way to discuss useful games in well-defined manner. One of the biggest problems with educational games is that they are often a non-game activity which has had game elements bolted onto it. That does not make it a game, nor does it make it play. We shall return to this.
Johan Huizinga
Homo Ludens

Bernard Suits
The Grasshopper

Eric Zimmerman
The Rules We Break

Helen Fioratti
Playing Games

Johan Huizinga – Homo Ludens
At its core, Homo Ludens is about the necessity of play to culture and society. Animals play, but humans play in ways that assist us in becoming more than a small in-group, limited by the Dunbar limit and the size of our cerebellum. Play, to Huizinga, is one of the primary drivers that creates culture and is necessary if we are to generate culture. (We need more than play but there must be play.)
Huizinga, in a rather dour way, leads off with the fact that play must be fun, which is why animals also do it despite many of the playful species lacking the additional brain stuff that we and other sentients or proto-sentients appear to have.
As Caillois agreed with (mostly), Huizinga had five rules: that play is free, it is not everyday life and in fact it is noticeably different from everyday life, play has a sense of absolute order (think rules here), and nobody actually benefits in any real or monetary sense from play.
Play was not just free, play was freedom, and that concept explains a lot of the subsequent rules and text. Although Huizinga did not follow up on culture as Caillois would have liked, he did note that cultural perceptions change the nature of play: while western children might pretend to be an animal, a first-nations’ shaman would be culturally considered to have become one. Even the way that we talk about play shows how fragile our definitions are once we start thinking.
My paraphrase of all of this is that once we engage someone in play, they will potentially engage with the activity that we had planned, all the while inhabiting a totally different context due to their own cultural experience and perception.
This is not a book I can summarise easily as it has an enormous amount of classification, ideas, and content. I will share some important ideas from or derived from the work that I am using in developing new tools:
- The “magic circle”: this is the space in which the normal rules of reality are suspended and others now apply.
- The notion of metaphor as play, the metaphorical representation of wisdom/lesson as god forming myth in a model that is inherently playful. Thus all myth-making, a strong civilising force, is a playful activity.
- Poetry is play. I just like this one.
Bernard Suits – The Grasshopper
Words cannot contain how much I love this book. Suits takes direct aim at Wittgenstein’s assertion that definition is impossible, demonstrated by an inability to define what games are, by providing a definition. But he does so through the most charming and heart-wrenching of conceits. You are probably familiar with the fable of the hard working ants and the lazy grasshopper, where the ants worked all summer and the grasshopper just played music, then winter came and the ants lived and the grasshopper died because … ants are just not very nice, apparently. The conceit at the core of “The Grasshopper” is that the grasshopper is a philosopher of play and can thus not commit to beneficial labour as it contradicts his principles. He makes great contributions in his philosophical discourse with his students (ants dressed up as grasshoppers), who beseech him to take food that they have worked for, for him, but he refuses, committed at the deepest level to his philosophy of play.
Suits’ rules (slightly paraphrased) are:
- There are a set of rules for the game
- You cannot take the most direct path to achieve the outcome
- Players willingly accept both the previous rules, adopting a ludic mindset.
As you can see, we’re back in the realm of an excursion from reality, with its own rules, mind space, and no definition of benefit. In fact, the Grasshopper provides an example of total detriment by comparison but he would rather die firm in his philosophy than give up his principles
I am not doing this book justice, but I hope I am conveying its essence. I draw on this in a lot of what I do, as a communicator, because I am always seeking to draw people into a semi-ludic space to explore new ideas and I must have their consent and commitment to the ludic mindset to do it: people must give themselves the authority and freedom to play.
Eric Zimmerman – The Rules We Break
This is a book about how to actually make games but also how to evolve and adapt games. Zimmerman goes through possible problems with games and is also reinforcing all the things that people want to see in games: is a game too predictable, does a winner emerge too early, do people drop out too fast, or is it simply “not fun”?
There are many notionally educational games that are merely the activity in question with a strange game frame around, in the style of “Let’s get to Mars by solving this algebra problem”, which often fall very rapidly into the “not fun” category because it’s not a game at all. It’s a learning activity with set process and correct outcome, wearing some silly clothes.
This is another book about design, very hands on, and built to try things. Imagine running students through a redevelopment of a combined text generation exercise as a game where one student writes the title, another writes the slug, another writes key elements, but they only have two words to do it from without any discussion, then they combine it and look at the whole they’ve created from that cue. Not only does this book drive that sort of creativity, it helps you to analyse whether it’s working and how to fix it.
You will look at games differently after reading this book AND have lots of great things to try in the classroom.
Helen Fioratti – Playing Games
Again, many books could be here but I have a soft spot for this one as I picked it up in Florence while I was starting my ponderings about games. There are so many different games in the world, card games alone would keep you busy for a lifetime, let alone variants on boardgames.
In many ways, understanding what has gone before is both informative and interesting, and understanding the rise of new games as new technologies or practices emerged is important to thinking about games in general. Why did a certain game gain a particular variant? How do games change when they are played with a “house” (casino) vs playing against other people?
As I noted, there was a time where people played games of chance without understanding probability. Oh wait, that’s Vegas. I’ve never been to Vegas because it scares the hell out of me – it’s like a trap invented for people who sometimes think that they are more clever than they are.
Games are part of who we are, who we were, and who we hope to be. A good historical reference of games is essential and this one is quite acceptable.
Summary
I hope that I have now motivated why play is both essential and useful as a tool, given that it allows us to move into another space with other rules – ideal for us seeking to get students to experiment and engage in new spaces with less overhead. So let’s get to the final two books in my collection that are relevant here.
Peterson and Smith
The Rapid Prototyping Game

Engelstein and Shalev
Building blocks of Tabletop Design
Engelstein and Shalev – Building Blocks of Tablerop Game Design
An incredible reference and the most amazing way to understand every game you’ve every played and every game mechanic you’ve ever used elsewhere. It’s almost impossible to read sequentially as, despite being very thorough and technically interesting, it’s an encyclopaedia, not a narrative work.
In many ways it’s the archetype (with the design guide above) of the written work that I discuss below: a well-written, technically correct, and thorough capture that introduces every important concept, paradigm, framework, methodology etc.
It also gives an example of the way that categories matter in the formation of the work. A different set of categorisation choices would put some things in a very, very different place.
Peterson and Smith – The Rapid Prototyping Game
Finally, the cards that inspired the tool that I’m currently working on – there are substantial and meaningful differences but the cards themselves made me think of what else we could do. Smith wanted to teach his game design students other techniques and wanted to engage them and mentioned to Peterson that he wanted a good range of techniques to draw from. You can find his own blog on this here. Smith found the encyclopaedia above (Engelstein and Shalev) and thought it was a great resource that he could turn into a playful activity by using cards. Why? because what he was trying to do wasn’t working
“You see, the students were still struggling. They were afraid of failing. They were unoriginal. They made games like Chutes and Ladders or Monopoly.”
Smith, https://www.gamedeveloper.com/design/the-rapid-prototyping-game
His goal: build something the students could play with that broke a complex task down into well-defined and manageable categories that enabled the students to isolate particular categories and work on them. Decomposition, simplification, and information management all being used to make something complex far easier to work with. By using random allocation, via the cards, he was able to break students out of their “I’m going to make Monopoly” because they might not get the elements to do it – in fact, it was quite unlikely.
Smith and Peterson’s model used three dice throws to establish medium (board, card,…) , format (competitive, cooperative,…) , and objective (exploration, building,…). Then they used four decks of cards to let students draw from a much larger range of options for Mechanics, Themes, Victory Condition and Turn Order.
For the tool I’m working on, we have more decks of cards, because a 6-sided die only allows six options, whereas we often have up to twenty. While what I’m doing is definitely inspired by this approach, it is more inspired by the idea of play as a super-positional rule space that allows exploration in a free space with different rules, which I approach far more formally than the original card authors do.
Final Summary
Thus, my books on play along with, not promised at all, an unpacking of my process that led towards the idea that my wonderful colleague Dr Rebecca Vivian then reified as the cards themselves. I hope to be able to share more on this soon.
Reflection: Why I’m stopping daily updates
Posted: February 15, 2016 Filed under: Education | Tags: aesthetics, authenticity, beauty, blogging, design, education, ethics, higher education, learning, reflection, teaching, thinking 6 CommentsI’ve written a lot in the past month and a half. Now, because I’m committed to evaluation, I have to look back at all of it and think about some difficult matters:
- Is anyone reading this?
- Are the people reading this the ones who can make change?
- Is the best way to do this?
- Should I be doing something else?
There are roughly 1,000 people who see my posts, between direct subscribers who read in e-mail, Facebook and the elusive following community on Twitter.
Twitter shouldn’t count, as I know from direct experience that the click-through rate from Twitter is tiny. (My posts have been shared by people with 5-10,000 followers and it has turned into maybe 10-20 more people reading.) Now I’m down to maybe 4-500 readers.
Facebook shares a longer fragment of my ideas but the click through is still small. Perhaps this brings me down to the roughly 200 followers I have, who have (over time) contributed about 1,000 ‘Likes’. However, almost all of these positive reinforcements stem from a different phase of the blog, a time when I was blogging conferences and being useful, rather than pontificating on the nature of beauty. My readership used to be 100 people a day, or more. I can’t crack 80 today and the way that I’m blogging is unlikely to reach that larger audience, yet it’s what I want to do.
The answer to 1 is that a few other people a day are reading what I write. I’d put it as high as twenty on a good day but most days it’s under ten.
2’s a tricky question. We can all make change; that’s one of my firmest beliefs. However, there is making change and then there are change makers. I know several people in this area quite well and they read me occasionally but it’s not something that they dedicate time to do. I have people that I always read but I can’t make the changes they need. It’s frustrating. No doubt, my ideas appeal to some people but change takes will and capacity to change, not just a sympathetic ear. I don’t want people to read this and feel trapped because they can’t make change. The answer to 2 is, probably, ‘no’.
3 follows from 1 and 2. If my readership is small and my ideas have little influence then this is not the best way to do things. We face enormous challenges. We need effective mechanisms for sharing information. If I am to make change, I have to invest my time wisely. I am not a large-scale player or a change maker. I need help to do it and if that help isn’t coming from this avenue, I have to choose another.
4 is easier. I can focus on my scholarship, practice, and research, rededicating the time I’ve been spending on this blog. People read papers where they don’t read blogs. Papers drive recognition. Recognition gets you the places to speak where your voice can be heard. There is no point having written all those words in a blog if it’s rarely read. This has been a highly rewarding experience in many ways but you have to wonder why you’re doing it if very few people read it or remember what you’ve written.
I wanted people to think and to talk about the ideas shared here. For those of you who have let me know that this worked, my thanks!
I’m tempted to keep going with the daily blog but the aesthetic argument traps me here. Spending time on something that isn’t working and insisting that it’s valuable is self-deception. Investing energy into an avenue that isn’t achieving your goals isn’t good. I cannot deprive my students of the hour or so a day that I’ve been spending doing this unless I achieve more for them than I would by doing some other aspect of my job.
Students and teachers: the true focus of any aesthetic discussion of education; the most important aspects of any discussion of what we should be doing because they are people and not just machine parts. As for us, so for them.
There are more discussions to be had but they’ll show up in more formal places, most likely. I’m always happy to talk to people about ideas at conferences. I’ve already started a face-to-face discussion about taking some of these ideas further in a more traditional research sense and I’m very excited about that.
But perhaps it’s time to let this blog go, listen to the numbers, reflect on the dissemination of knowledge, and accept that I would not be following my own advice if I were to continue. I love the beauty argument. I think it’s great. I stand by everything I’ve written this year. I just don’t think that this is the way to move people towards that agenda.
Thus, the daily updates stop with this post. I’ll still post things that interest me but there’ll be fewer of them.
I’ll leave you with the message I wanted to get across this year:
- Educational philosophy is full of the aesthetics of education. Dewey and Bloom just scratch the surface of this. The late 19th and early 20th century were an incredible time of upheaval and we still haven’t addressed many of the questions raised then. To the libraries!
- Fair, equitable, well-designed and evidence-based education is at the core of any beautiful system.
- Every day, we should ask ourselves if what we are doing is beautiful, good or true, taking into account all of the difficult questions of how we balance necessities against desirabilities, being honest about which is which. If we aren’t managing this, we need to either seek to change or accept that what we are doing isn’t right.
- We should leave enough time for ourselves in all of this, as there should be no sacrificial element to beautiful education.
- Change is coming. Change is here. Pretending that it won’t happen isn’t beautiful.
I hope that you all have a fantastic learning and teaching year, with many amazing and beautiful moments and outcomes!
This year, I hope to be at several conferences and I look forward to talking to anyone about the ideas in this phase (or any other phase) of the blog.
Have a great year!

More on the #ATAR, @birmo looks to the Higher Education Standards Panel
Posted: February 11, 2016 Filed under: Education | Tags: advocacy, ATAR, authenticity, community, education, educational problem, educational research, ethics, higher education, reflection, resources, tertiary admittance, tools 1 CommentThe Federal Education Minister, Senator Simon Birmingham, appears as concerned over the disconnect between the Australian Tertiary Admission Rank (ATAR) and university entry as I am. In his own words, students must have “a clear understanding of what they need to do to get into their course of choice and realising what will be expected of them through their further study.”
This article covers some of the issues already raised over transparency and having a system that people work with rather than around.
“While universities determine their own admission requirements, exploring greater transparency measures will ensure that Australian students are provided real information on what they need to do to be admitted to a course at a particular institution and universities are held to account for their public entry requirements,” Senator Birmingham said.
Ensuring that students are ready for university but it’s increasingly obvious that this role is not supported or validated through the current ATAR system, for a large number of students. I look forward to see what comes from the standards panel and I hope that it’s to everyone’s benefit, not just a rejigging of a number that was probably never all that representative to start with.

Senator Birmingham, Minister Pyne, Professor Bebbington (VC of Adelaide) and A/Prof Katrina Falkner with one of the Bright Spark participants.
Perhaps I should confess that I would like a system where any student could get into University (or VET or TAFE or whatever tertiary program they want to) but that we build our preparatory and educational systems to support this happening, rather than just bringing people in to watch them fail. Oh, but a boy can dream.
Streamlining for meaning.
Posted: February 9, 2016 Filed under: Education | Tags: advocacy, aesthetics, assessment, authenticity, beauty, competency-based assessment, design, education, educational problem, educational research, ethics, GPA, higher education, in the student's head, reflection, resources, student perspective, teaching, teaching approaches, thinking Leave a commentIn yesterday’s musings on Grade Point Average, GPA, I said:
But [GPA calculation adjustment] have to be a method of avoidance, this can be a useful focusing device. If a student did really well in, say, Software Engineering but struggled with an earlier, unrelated, stream, why can’t we construct a GPA for Software Engineering that clearly states the area of relevance and degree of information? Isn’t that actually what employers and people interested in SE want to know?
This hits at the heart of my concerns over any kind of summary calculation that obscures the process. Who does this benefit? What use it is to anyone? What does it mean? Let’s look at one of the most obvious consumers of student GPAs: the employers and industry.
Feedback from the Australian industry tells us that employers are generally happy with the technical skills that we’re providing but it’s the softer skills (interpersonal skills, leadership, management abilities) that they would like to see more of and know more about. A general GPA doesn’t tell you this but a Software Engineering focused GPA (as I mentioned above) would show you how a student performed in courses where we would expect to see these skills introduced and exercised.
Putting everything into one transcript gives people the power to assemble this themselves, yes, but this requires the assembler to know what everything means. Most employers have neither the time nor inclination to do this for all 39 or so institutions in Australia. But if a University were to say “this is a summary of performance in these graduate attributes”, where the GAs are regularly focused on the softer skills, then we start to make something more meaningful out of an arbitrary number.
But let’s go further. If we can see individual assessments, rather than coarse subject grades, we can start to construct a model of an individual across the different challenges that they have faced and overcome. Portfolios are, of course, a great way to do this but they’re more work to read than single measures and, too often, such a portfolio is weighed against simpler, apparently meaningful measures such as high GPAs and found wanting. Portfolios also struggle if placed into a context of previous failure, even if recent activity clearly demonstrates that a student has moved on from that troubled or difficult time.
I have a deep ethical and philosophical objection to curve grading, as you probably know. The reason is simple: the actions of one student should not negatively affect the outcomes of another. This same objection is my biggest problem with GPA, although in this case the action and outcomes belong to the same student at different points in her or his life. Rather than using performance in one course to determine access to the learning upon which it depends, we make these grades a permanent effect and every grade that comes afterwards is implicitly mediated through this action.

Sometimes you should be cautious regarding adding curves to address your problems.
Should Past Academic Nick have an inescapable impact on Now and Future Academic Nick’s life? When we look at all of the external influences on success, which make it clear how much totally non-academic things matter, it gets harder and harder to say “Yes, Past Academic Nick is inescapable.” Unfairness is rarely aesthetically pleasing.
An excellent comment on the previous post raised the issue of comparing GPAs in an environment where the higher GPA included some fails but the slightly lower GPA student had always passed. Which was the ‘best’ student from an award perspective? Student A fails three courses at the start of his degree, student B fails three courses at the end. Both pass with the same GPA, time to completion, and number of passes and fails. Is there even a sense of ‘better student’ here? B’s struggles are more immediate and, implicitly, concerns would be raised that these problems could still be active. A has, apparently, moved on in some way. But we’d never know this from simplistic calculations.
If we’re struggling to define ‘best’ and we’re not actually providing something that many people feel is useful, while burdening students with an inescapable past, then the least we can do is to sit down with the people who are affected by this and ask them what they really want.
And then, when they tell us, we do something about changing our systems.
Total control: a user model for student results
Posted: February 7, 2016 Filed under: Education | Tags: aesthetics, beauty, design, education, educational problem, ethics, higher education, in the student's head, reflection, resources, teaching, teaching approaches, thinking, tools Leave a commentYesterday, I wrote:
We need assessment systems that work for the student first and everyone else second.
Grades are the fossils of evaluation
Posted: February 6, 2016 Filed under: Education | Tags: advocacy, aesthetics, assessment, authenticity, competency-based assessment, design, education, educational problem, educational research, fossil, higher education, in the student's head, learning, ranking, reflection, resources, student perspective, teaching, teaching approaches, thinking, truth, Wolff 1 CommentAssessments support evaluation, criticism and ranking (Wolff). That’s what it does and, in many cases, that also constitutes a lot of why we do it. But who are we doing it for?
I’ve reflected on the dual nature of evaluation, showing a student her or his level of progress and mastery while also telling us how well the learning environment is working. In my argument to reduce numerical grades to something meaningful, I’ve asked what the actual requirement is for our students, how we measure mastery and how we can build systems to provide this.
But who are the student’s grades actually for?
In terms of ranking, grades allow people who are not the student to place the students in some order. By doing this, we can award awards to students who are in the awarding an award band (repeated word use deliberate). We can restrict our job interviews to students who are summa cum laude or valedictorian or Dean’s Merit Award Winner. Certain groups of students, not all, like to define their progress through comparison so there is a degree of self-ranking but, for the most part, ranking is something that happens to students.
Criticism, in terms of providing constructive, timely feedback to assist the student, is weakly linked to any grading system. Giving someone a Fail grade isn’t a critique as it contains no clear identification of the problems. The clear identification of problems may not constitute a fail. Often these correlate but it’s weak. A student’s grades are not going to provide useful critique to the student by themselves. These grades are to allow us to work out if the student has met our assessment mechanisms to a point where they can count this course as a pre-requisite or can be awarded a degree. (Award!)
Evaluation is, as noted, useful to us and the student but a grade by itself does not contain enough record of process to be useful in evaluating how mastery goals were met and how the learning environment succeeded or failed. Competency, when applied systematically, does have a well-defined meaning. A passing grade does not although there is an implied competency and there is a loose correlation with achievement.
Grades allow us to look at all of a student’s work as if this one impression is a reflection of the student’s involvement, engagement, study, mistakes, triumphs, hopes and dreams. They are additions to a record from which we attempt to reconstruct a living, whole being.
Grades are the fossils of evaluation.
Grades provide a mechanism for us, in a proxy role as academic archaeologist, to classify students into different groups, in an attempt to project colour into grey stone, to try and understand the ecosystem that such a creature would live in, and to identify how successful this species was.
As someone who has been a student several times in my life, I’m aware that I have a fossil record that is not traditional for an academic. I was lucky to be able to place a new imprint in the record, to obscure my history as a much less successful species, and could then build upon it until I became an ACADEMIC TYRANNOSAURUS.

LIFE LONG LEARNING, ROAARRRR!
But I’m lucky. I’m privileged. I had a level of schooling and parental influence that provided me with an excellent vocabulary and high social mobility. I live in a safe city. I have a supportive partner. And, more importantly, at a crucial moment in my life, someone who knew me told me about an opportunity that I was able to pursue despite the grades that I had set in stone. A chance came my way that I never would have thought of because I had internalised my grades as my worth.
Let’s look at the fossil record of Nick.
My original GPA fossil, encompassing everything that went wrong and right in my first degree, was 2.9. On a scale of 7, which is how we measure it, that’s well below a pass average. I’m sharing that because I want you to put that fact together with what happened next. Four years later, I started a Masters program that I finished with a GPA of 6.4. A few years after the masters, I decided to go and study wine making. That degree was 6.43. Then I received a PhD, with commendation, that is equivalent to GPA 7. (We don’t actually use GPA in research degrees. Hmmm.) If my grade record alone lobbed onto your desk you would see the desiccated and dead snapshot of how I (failed to) engage with the University system. A lot of that is on me but, amazingly, it appears that much better things were possible. That original grade record stopped me from getting interviews. Stopped me from getting jobs. When I was finally able to demonstrate the skills that I had, which weren’t bad, I was able to get work. Then I had the opportunity to rewrite my historical record.
Yes, this is personal for me. But it’s not about me because I wasn’t trapped by this. I was lucky as well as privileged. I can’t emphasise that enough. The fact that you are reading this is due to luck. That’s not a good enough mechanism.
Too many students don’t have this opportunity. That impression in the wet mud of their school life will harden into a stone straitjacket from which they may never escape. The way we measure and record grades has far too much potential to work against students and the correlation with actual ability is there but it’s not strong and it’s not always reliable.
The student you are about to send out with a GPA of 2.9 may be competent and they are, most definitely, more than that number.
The recording of grades is a high-loss storage record of the student’s learning and pathway to mastery. It allows us to conceal achievement and failure alike in the accumulation of mathematical aggregates that proxy for competence but correlate weakly.
We need assessment systems that work for the student first and everyone else second.


